Intratio
Loading...
Skip to main content
Stock comparison · Signal date 2026-11-04

ACGL vs AIG: stock comparison and AI forecast

Arch Capital Group Ltd. (ACGL) and American International Group, Inc. (AIG) compared on price performance, valuation, profitability and the daily AI forecast. · Alpha · vs market

Share
Nasdaq · Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance

ACGL Arch Capital Group Ltd.

Market Cap
$36.78B
P/E Ratio
8.4x
Size
large-cap
AI Forecast
Full analysis →
NYSE · Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance

AIG American International Group, Inc.

Market Cap
$42.11B
P/E Ratio
14.7x
Size
large-cap
AI Forecast
Full analysis →
Model output

Which one does the AI model favor?

Intratio's model scores both stocks every trading day. Sign in to see their current direction; the exact ratings and forecasts come with a plan or a free follow slot.

ACGL · AIG

Key facts

  • AIG is 1.1 times larger than ACGL by market capitalization ($42.11B against $36.78B).
  • ACGL trades at 8.4 times trailing earnings, AIG at 14.7 times.
  • ACGL turns 24.4% of its revenue into net income, against 11.1% for AIG.
  • AIG carries 3.03 times debt per unit of equity, against 2.54 times for ACGL.
  • AIG yields 2.36% in dividends; ACGL pays none.
  • Both companies share the SEC industry classification Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance.
Fundamentals

Fundamentals side by side

Trailing twelve months.

Valuation & Market

MetricACGLAIG
Market Cap$36.78B$42.11B
P/E Ratio8.44x14.70x
P/B Ratio1.53x1.04x
Dividend Yield–2.36%
EPS$12.77$5.48
Book Value/Share$70.42$77.66
Revenue/Share$56.36$50.94
FCF/Share$17.74–

Profitability & Margins

MetricACGLAIG
ROE19.5%7.3%
ROA5.5%1.8%
Net Margin24.4%11.1%
EBT Margin–13.6%
Tax Rate–18.2%

Financial Health

MetricACGLAIG
D/E Ratio2.54x3.03x
Financial Leverage3.54x4.03x

Cash Flow

MetricACGLAIG
Operating Cash Flow$6.10B$3.85B
Free Cash Flow$6.05B–
Capital Spending-$45M–
OCF Growth YoY-1.2%21.9%
FCF Growth YoY-1.2%–
FCF/Sales31.5%–
CapEx/Sales0.2%–

Operational Efficiency

MetricACGLAIG
Asset Turnover0.23x0.16x

Income Statement

MetricACGLAIG
Total Revenue$19.23B$26.64B
Net Income$4.69B$2.96B
SG&A Expense–$5.14B

Dividend & Shareholder Information

MetricACGLAIG
Dividends Per Share–$1.90
Payout Ratio–34.7%
Shares Outstanding341M523M
Net Income Growth25.7%-7.3%
EPS Growth31.9%5.6%
FAQ

ACGL vs AIG: stock comparison and AI forecast

Which is bigger, ACGL or AIG?

AIG is 1.1 times larger than ACGL by market capitalization ($42.11B against $36.78B).

Which is cheaper on earnings, ACGL or AIG?

ACGL trades at 8.4 times trailing earnings, AIG at 14.7 times.

Which one does Intratio's AI model rank higher, ACGL or AIG?

Intratio's model scores both stocks every trading day. Sign in to see their current direction; the exact ratings and forecasts come with a plan or a free follow slot.

Compare

More comparisons

This analysis is generated automatically using our proprietary AI systems and should not be considered personalized investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always conduct your own research and consider consulting a financial advisor before making investment decisions.